Talk:Zionism

zionism is a bourgoise nationalism ...

josef stalin

Unsourced

 * To be fair, one can oppose Zionism. It is intrinsically [[anti-Semitic{] to do so, in the year 2019, of course. As I wrote last Friday, anti-Zionism was "a legitimate academic debate in the half-century between Herzl's initial formulation and Ben-Gurion's ultimate declaration, but ... now serves as the thinnest of all thinly veiled ruses for genocidal aspirants who want to throw all the Juden into the Mediterranean." Indeed, just as one can be an unvarnished Jew-hater, one can surely still oppose Zionism. One can personally hold any number of vile beliefs.
 * I have put the source under the quote on the page. --2001:8003:4163:AD00:80BA:B63E:E0BF:2C3E 10:24, 19 June 2019 (UTC)
 * The author is not notable and doesn't seem WQ:Q, needs consensus to stay here. Maybe User:Evanvalken can give us an opinion on it. Rupert Loup 08:35, 24 June 2019 (UTC)
 * its quotable, and its notable more so for the media outlet then the author. --1.136.111.245 09:55, 24 June 2019 (UTC)
 * WQ:Q states: "Is the author or work from which the quote comes notable?", the quote still didn't achive the endurance factor because their recentism, and the author is quoting themselve so we should be discusing the original quote first and foremost. Rupert Loup 12:10, 24 June 2019 (UTC)
 * WQ:NQUOTE also states:
 * "The quote is from a notable person." Which this author is not.
 * "The quote is from an expert on the article topic and appears in a notable publication." Which the source is not. It is not from an academic publication. It doesn't have the weight to be here. Rupert Loup 13:30, 24 June 2019 (UTC)

Has the quote stood the test of time? Too early to tell
 * Is the quote verifiably sourced? Yes
 * Is the quote original to the author to whom or work to which it is being attributed? Yes
 * Is the subject of the quote a notable subject? Is it about a broad theme of the human experience such as Love, Justice, or Loneliness? Or is it about a narrow or mundane topic, like porcupines, lunch meat, or that new car smell? If the quote is about a mundane topic, does the author have particular expertise on that topic? If the quote is about another person, is that other person highly notable? Zionism is a notable topic
 * Is the author or work from which the quote comes notable? If so, are they very notable, moderately notable, barely notable? Are they notable as a source of quotes (i.e., as a poet, pundit, or Yogi Berra)? The source which the quote comes from is notable
 * Is the quote itself particularly witty, pithy, wise, eloquent, or poignant? It's wise
 * Is the quote itself independently well known (as with proverbs and certain well-reported comments)? No

There you go. --1.136.105.34 05:08, 26 June 2019 (UTC)