Wikiquote:Votes for deletion/Category:Subcultures

Category: Subcultures
Overly broad category: every profession, hobby, fandom, nationality, sexuality and religion is a subculture anywhere it isn't the main culture; and culture by the way isn't a category. This category also suggests we want pages for all the other high school cliques that typically accompany nerd and that pages for fandoms should be distinct from the actual works or groups they are associated with. Wikipedia considers Juggalos to be in the musical subculture category, despite being specific to one band, is this how our subculture category should be divided? Should we have a page for Trekkie separate from Star Trek? I think Wikipedia has a lot of pages and categories that would not improve Wikiquote and this is one of them. — CensoredScribe (talk) 20:00, 2 December 2018 (UTC)
 * Vote closes: 21:00, 9 December 2018 (UTC)
 * Keep? - There is no sense in which having a category implies that we need have pages on every subject that falls into that category. I am, as far as I am aware, a member of Category:Humans and not Category:Robots. But I am neither notable nor quotable, so I don't get a page on Wikiquote. Beyond that, every minority is not necessarily meaningfully a subculture. It is not merely a numerical demographic statement; it is a group where their ideological separation from and diametric opposition to the dominate culture is somehow central to their identity. The Episcopal Church is a numerical minority in the United States, but they are not a subculture in the sociological sense that part of their core identity is embodied in running counter to the dominant culture. They are primarily a group that is a variant on, rather than an opposition to or rebellion against the dominant culture.  G M G  talk  14:25, 3 December 2018 (UTC)