Wikiquote:Votes for deletion/Nupur J. Sharma

Nupur J. Sharma
Fails Notability and WQ:Quotability — Akhiljaxxn (talk) 11:05, 30 November 2020 (UTC)


 * Keep. Notable author and journalist. One of her books was in the top 1 position in the Amazon Best Sellers Rank  It was #1 Best Seller in Kindle Store Amazon India across all categories. That fact alone makes the author highly notable. Also the author has almost half a million Twitter followers and for example among her notable interviews she interviewed the founder of this website. Also the precedent is to keep articles if they are notable despite not yet having a corresponding wikipedia articles, see the prior deletion discussions of Mekhala Krishnamurthy Neethi Padmanabhan Armin Rosencranz which all were kept after deletion discussion. Wikiquote has thousands of articles that are much less notable and this article meets notability clearly. Obviously when trillions of other lesser known people exist on Wikiquote, its unfair that investigative  journalists or media critics are nominated for deletion because of their views. The problem is this: There are trillions of less notable pages here and they dont get deleted. Why? Because no one cares. But in the case of say an investigative journalist, or a media critic, then it is a problem (unless the notability cannot be denied anymore such as for Julian Assange or Snowden). Usually any other lesser-known XYZ person wouldnt have the problem with getting nominated for deletion. It applies to any controversial article, on topics with strongly different opinions and where editors of different beliefs are editing, thats where the problem lies. Currently, Wikiquote doesnt have any policies about how to deal with this effectively. New policies have to be made to deal with this. I dont know whats a good solution for this.  But we do not censor, see Wikiquote is not censored and WP:IDONTLIKEIT.

The user Akhiljaxxn was edit-warring previously, made extreme personal attacks on WQ [https://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Steward_requests/Global_permissions&diff=prev&oldid=20347851#Global_rename_for_Akhiljaxxn was edit-warring many times, did canvassing and forum shopping this could be part of it and only edits articles about the opposition party in India about which he deleted all quotes that are not 100 percent positive about the political party. ] --ო (talk) 12:12, 15 December 2020 (UTC) The forum shopping and canvassing on other websites were done by somebody else, I mistakenly attributed the forum shopping and canvassing to this user, striking through, but the extreme personal attacks were done by this user. This user has made extreme personal attacks across wikiquote against the No personal attack policy. Personal attacks should never be used in Wikiquote..

--ო (talk) 12:20, 15 December 2020 (UTC), , , , this article has been here for many months, can it be closed? -- ო ~ #SheSaid 10:36, 21 March 2021 (UTC)
 * Keep per დამოკიდებულება i would like to trout the nominater for not even googling the subject to see Notablity before nominating.Ratnahastin (talk) 12:07, 15 July 2021 (UTC)

Vote closes: 12:00, 7 December 2020 (UTC)